Reaching climate and industrial policy objectives during global fragmentation
Basic materials such as steel, aluminium and chemicals cause around 30% of global CO2 emissions. Free allocation under the EU ETS protects them against carbon leakage, but it weakens incentives for clean production and efficient material use. With global fragmentation, a carbon border adjustment based on production-specific values cannot fully provide carbon leakage protection and thereby incentives for clean production and material efficiency.
In this video, Karsten Neuhoff and Fernanda Ballesteros (DIW Berlin) discuss a reform option of shifting to EU ETS and CBAM with standardized value, for sectors with complex value chains. Producers continue to receive free allowances at the full conventional benchmark. In addition, they incure a standardised liability per tonne of material, which is passed along the value chain, applied to imports and waived for exports. This keeps the carbon price signal, creates a business case for clean production and ensures a level playing field.
The presentation is based on joint work with Lars Zetterberg and Johan Rootzén (IVL Swedish Environmental Research Institute), Nicolas Berghmans (IDDRI), Neila Khelifi, Sini Matikainen and Misato Sato (Grantham Research Institute / CETEx, LSE), Aleksander Śniegocki and Aneta Stefańczyk (IREFORM), Pedro Linares (IIT Comillas), Karsten Neuhoff, Fernanda Ballesteros, Antonia Kurz and Thibault Deletombe (DIW Berlin), and Balázs Felsmann (REKK).
📚 Further Reading
▸ Glossary: CBAM (Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism) https://www.diw.de/en/diw_01.c.1009461.en/cbam_____carbon_border_adjustment_mechanism.html
▸Q&A: CBAM based on standardized values https://www.diw.de/en/diw_01.c.955442.en/cbam_based_on_standardized_values_q_a.html
📄 Publications
▸ Neuhoff, K., Ballesteros, F., Kurz, A., Niemöller, P. (2025): Reform des CO2-Grenzausgleichs ist entscheidend für wettbewerbsfähige Industrie [Reform of the carbon border adjustment is crucial for a competitive industry]. DIW Wochenbericht 47/2025 (in German). https://www.diw.de/de/diw_01.c.987923.de/publikationen/wochenberichte/2025_47_4/reform_des_co2-grenzausgleichs_ist_entscheidend_fuer_wettbewerbsfaehige_industrie.html
▸ Neuhoff, K., Sato, M., Ballesteros, F. et al. (2026): Industrial Decarbonization in a Fragmented World: Carbon Pricing with Border Adjustments Using Standardized Values. Energy Policy 216, 115405. https://www.diw.de/de/diw_01.c.1009000.de/publikationen/externe_referierte_aufsaetze/2026_0000/industrial_decarbonization_in_a_fragmented_world__carbon_pricing_with_border_adjustments_using_standardized_values.html
▸ Le Den, X., Fallmann, H., Görlach, B., Ismer, R., Neuhoff, K., Stede, J., Steinmann, J. (2021): Study on the Possibility to Set up a Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism on Selected Sectors: Final Report. Brussels: European Union. https://www.diw.de/de/diw_01.c.824231.de/publikationen/externe_monographien/2021/study_on_the_possibility_to_set_up_a_carbon_border_adjustment_mechanism_on_selected_sectors__final_report.html
▸ Stede, J., Pauliuk, S., Hardadi, G., Neuhoff, K. (2021): Carbon Pricing of Basic Materials: Incentives and Risks for the Value Chain and Consumers. Ecological Economics 189, 107168. https://www.diw.de/de/diw_01.c.826322.de/publikationen/externe_referierte_aufsaetze/2021_0000/carbon_pricing_of_basic_materials__incentives_and_risks_for_the_value_chain_and_consumers.html
Chapters
0:00 Introduction
0:28 How carbon pricing creates incentives along the value chain
3:32 Free allocation and the carbon leakage problem
10:12 The reform proposal: ETS and CBAM with standardized values
17:09 Summary and outlook
Basic materials such as steel, aluminium and chemicals cause around 30% of global CO2 emissions. Free allocation under the EU ETS protects them against carbon leakage, but it weakens incentives for clean production and efficient material use. With global fragmentation, a carbon border adjustment based on production-specific values cannot fully provide carbon leakage protection and thereby incentives for clean production and material efficiency.
In this video, Karsten Neuhoff and Fernanda Ballesteros (DIW Berlin) discuss a reform option of shifting to EU ETS and CBAM with standardized value, for sectors with complex value chains. Producers continue to receive free allowances at the full conventional benchmark. In addition, they incure a standardised liability per tonne of material, which is passed along the value chain, applied to imports and waived for exports. This keeps the carbon price signal, creates a business case for clean production and ensures a level playing field.
The presentation is based on joint work with Lars Zetterberg and Johan Rootzén (IVL Swedish Environmental Research Institute), Nicolas Berghmans (IDDRI), Neila Khelifi, Sini Matikainen and Misato Sato (Grantham Research Institute / CETEx, LSE), Aleksander Śniegocki and Aneta Stefańczyk (IREFORM), Pedro Linares (IIT Comillas), Karsten Neuhoff, Fernanda Ballesteros, Antonia Kurz and Thibault Deletombe (DIW Berlin), and Balázs Felsmann (REKK).
📚 Further Reading
▸ Glossary: CBAM (Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism) https://www.diw.de/en/diw_01.c.1009461.en/cbam_____carbon_border_adjustment_mechanism.html
▸Q&A: CBAM based on standardized values https://www.diw.de/en/diw_01.c.955442.en/cbam_based_on_standardized_values_q_a.html
📄 Publications
▸ Neuhoff, K., Ballesteros, F., Kurz, A., Niemöller, P. (2025): Reform des CO2-Grenzausgleichs ist entscheidend für wettbewerbsfähige Industrie [Reform of the carbon border adjustment is crucial for a competitive industry]. DIW Wochenbericht 47/2025 (in German). https://www.diw.de/de/diw_01.c.987923.de/publikationen/wochenberichte/2025_47_4/reform_des_co2-grenzausgleichs_ist_entscheidend_fuer_wettbewerbsfaehige_industrie.html
▸ Neuhoff, K., Sato, M., Ballesteros, F. et al. (2026): Industrial Decarbonization in a Fragmented World: Carbon Pricing with Border Adjustments Using Standardized Values. Energy Policy 216, 115405. https://www.diw.de/de/diw_01.c.1009000.de/publikationen/externe_referierte_aufsaetze/2026_0000/industrial_decarbonization_in_a_fragmented_world__carbon_pricing_with_border_adjustments_using_standardized_values.html
▸ Le Den, X., Fallmann, H., Görlach, B., Ismer, R., Neuhoff, K., Stede, J., Steinmann, J. (2021): Study on the Possibility to Set up a Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism on Selected Sectors: Final Report. Brussels: European Union. https://www.diw.de/de/diw_01.c.824231.de/publikationen/externe_monographien/2021/study_on_the_possibility_to_set_up_a_carbon_border_adjustment_mechanism_on_selected_sectors__final_report.html
▸ Stede, J., Pauliuk, S., Hardadi, G., Neuhoff, K. (2021): Carbon Pricing of Basic Materials: Incentives and Risks for the Value Chain and Consumers. Ecological Economics 189, 107168. https://www.diw.de/de/diw_01.c.826322.de/publikationen/externe_referierte_aufsaetze/2021_0000/carbon_pricing_of_basic_materials__incentives_and_risks_for_the_value_chain_and_consumers.html
Chapters
0:00 Introduction
0:28 How carbon pricing creates incentives along the value chain
3:32 Free allocation and the carbon leakage problem
10:12 The reform proposal: ETS and CBAM with standardized values
17:09 Summary and outlook
💬 Community-Diskussion & Kommentare
Starte die Diskussion im Social-Chat Broadcast Stream oder reiche oben über „✏️ Information ergänzen“ einen Fachbeitrag ein.