Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy raises a fundamental question about US security guarantees for Ukraine: Would American forces actually defend the country if Russia attacked again?
Speaking to journalists following the Coalition of the Willing summit in Berlin, Germany, on 19 November 2026, Zelenskyy discusses the possibility of NATO Article 5-style security guarantees without Ukraine formally joining the Alliance.
His remarks follow discussions with US President Donald Trump's representatives, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, about a potential peace agreement with Russia.
“What does Article 5 really mean?”
Zelenskyy welcomes discussions about stronger security commitments but questions whether Washington, Kyiv and European governments share the same understanding of what those guarantees would involve.
“I'm not sure that we have a common understanding of Article 5.”
For Zelenskyy, a political promise is not enough. Ukraine needs to know what would happen if Russia launched another invasion.
American troops and military bases in Ukraine?
One of the most striking moments comes when Zelenskyy raises the possibility of American military personnel and bases on Ukrainian territory.
“What about American soldiers?”
He points to countries outside NATO that host US military bases, questioning whether similar arrangements could form part of Ukraine's future security architecture.
Zelenskyy does not announce an agreement to establish American bases in Ukraine. Instead, he asks whether Washington would consider such commitments and acknowledges that he has not received a clear answer.
Trump's Article 5-style security proposal
US envoy Jared Kushner has suggested that Washington is open to a security guarantee modelled on NATO's collective-defence principle.
However, Zelenskyy stresses that the practical details remain unclear.
NATO's Article 5 establishes collective-defence obligations among Alliance members. A separate guarantee for Ukraine would require its own agreed commitments and would not automatically extend NATO membership or Article 5 protection to Kyiv.
“What will partners do if Russia attacks again?”
Zelenskyy says the most important question concerns the response to renewed Russian aggression.
“What will partners do?”
He warns that Ukraine needs clearly defined commitments from the United States and European partners, including the actions they would take in another crisis.
For Kyiv, effective deterrence requires more than diplomatic declarations.
Zelenskyy invokes September 11
The Ukrainian President refers to the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks in the United States and the strong international response that followed.
He uses the example to explain why security commitments must be accompanied by a credible capacity and willingness to act.
Zelenskyy argues that a future attack on Ukraine should trigger a clear response from its security partners.
Ukraine's reconstruction depends on security
Beyond military protection, Zelenskyy highlights the importance of security guarantees for Ukraine's economic recovery.
Investors, businesses and displaced Ukrainians considering returning home need confidence that renewed aggression will not destroy the country's reconstruction.
He argues that long-term economic stability depends on credible commitments from Ukraine's international partners.
“Article 5, but no NATO?”
Zelenskyy questions whether an Article 5-style guarantee outside NATO would provide sufficiently clear protection.
He acknowledges that full NATO membership would offer a more established collective-defence framework, while a separate arrangement would need detailed commitments regarding troops, enforcement and responses to aggression.
Could American soldiers become part of Ukraine's future security?
The Berlin discussions have brought NATO-style guarantees back into focus, but important questions remain unanswered.
For Zelenskyy, the central issue is whether Ukraine's partners would be prepared to take concrete action if Russia attacked again.
Would NATO-style guarantees without NATO membership be enough to deter Putin, or would Ukraine need American and European troops on its territory to secure a lasting peace?
#eudebates #Zelenskyy #Trump #NATO #Ukraine
Speaking to journalists following the Coalition of the Willing summit in Berlin, Germany, on 19 November 2026, Zelenskyy discusses the possibility of NATO Article 5-style security guarantees without Ukraine formally joining the Alliance.
His remarks follow discussions with US President Donald Trump's representatives, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, about a potential peace agreement with Russia.
“What does Article 5 really mean?”
Zelenskyy welcomes discussions about stronger security commitments but questions whether Washington, Kyiv and European governments share the same understanding of what those guarantees would involve.
“I'm not sure that we have a common understanding of Article 5.”
For Zelenskyy, a political promise is not enough. Ukraine needs to know what would happen if Russia launched another invasion.
American troops and military bases in Ukraine?
One of the most striking moments comes when Zelenskyy raises the possibility of American military personnel and bases on Ukrainian territory.
“What about American soldiers?”
He points to countries outside NATO that host US military bases, questioning whether similar arrangements could form part of Ukraine's future security architecture.
Zelenskyy does not announce an agreement to establish American bases in Ukraine. Instead, he asks whether Washington would consider such commitments and acknowledges that he has not received a clear answer.
Trump's Article 5-style security proposal
US envoy Jared Kushner has suggested that Washington is open to a security guarantee modelled on NATO's collective-defence principle.
However, Zelenskyy stresses that the practical details remain unclear.
NATO's Article 5 establishes collective-defence obligations among Alliance members. A separate guarantee for Ukraine would require its own agreed commitments and would not automatically extend NATO membership or Article 5 protection to Kyiv.
“What will partners do if Russia attacks again?”
Zelenskyy says the most important question concerns the response to renewed Russian aggression.
“What will partners do?”
He warns that Ukraine needs clearly defined commitments from the United States and European partners, including the actions they would take in another crisis.
For Kyiv, effective deterrence requires more than diplomatic declarations.
Zelenskyy invokes September 11
The Ukrainian President refers to the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks in the United States and the strong international response that followed.
He uses the example to explain why security commitments must be accompanied by a credible capacity and willingness to act.
Zelenskyy argues that a future attack on Ukraine should trigger a clear response from its security partners.
Ukraine's reconstruction depends on security
Beyond military protection, Zelenskyy highlights the importance of security guarantees for Ukraine's economic recovery.
Investors, businesses and displaced Ukrainians considering returning home need confidence that renewed aggression will not destroy the country's reconstruction.
He argues that long-term economic stability depends on credible commitments from Ukraine's international partners.
“Article 5, but no NATO?”
Zelenskyy questions whether an Article 5-style guarantee outside NATO would provide sufficiently clear protection.
He acknowledges that full NATO membership would offer a more established collective-defence framework, while a separate arrangement would need detailed commitments regarding troops, enforcement and responses to aggression.
Could American soldiers become part of Ukraine's future security?
The Berlin discussions have brought NATO-style guarantees back into focus, but important questions remain unanswered.
For Zelenskyy, the central issue is whether Ukraine's partners would be prepared to take concrete action if Russia attacked again.
Would NATO-style guarantees without NATO membership be enough to deter Putin, or would Ukraine need American and European troops on its territory to secure a lasting peace?
#eudebates #Zelenskyy #Trump #NATO #Ukraine
💬 Community-Diskussion & Kommentare
Starte die Diskussion im Social-Chat Broadcast Stream oder reiche oben über „✏️ Information ergänzen“ einen Fachbeitrag ein.